Rocket Recovery: SpaceX's Giant Catch

InfoThis is a summary of the following YouTube video:

How SpaceX Landed A Rocket... Without Landing Legs. Catching a Giant Rocket With Giant Chopsticks

Scott Manley

Oct 13, 2024

·

Science & Technology

SpaceX's innovative rocket landing success

  1. SpaceX's recent launch involved the Starship/SuperHeavy system, marking its fifth flight. This mission was particularly ambitious as it aimed to land the booster using a novel method involving a launch tower, known as Mechazilla, which catches the booster mid-air using small pins on its side.
  2. The mission was successful, achieving both the landing of the Super Heavy booster on the tower and the precise descent and landing of the Starship. This accomplishment highlights the advanced engineering and ingenuity involved, overcoming numerous potential challenges and uncertainties.
  3. Previous flights faced various issues, such as the first flight's 'rock tornado' that caused engine failures and loss of control, leading to a delayed flight termination. Subsequent flights introduced improvements like a water deluge system to protect engines and a hot staging system for better stage separation.
  4. Flight two's improvements led to a successful stage separation, although the booster exploded shortly after. The Starship continued but ran out of oxygen, resulting in flight termination. Flight three saw both stages completing their intended burns, but the booster was lost, and the Starship failed re-entry due to attitude control loss.
  5. Flight four introduced the jettisoning of the hot staging ring to reduce mass, allowing the booster to safely land in the Gulf of Mexico. This flight demonstrated the precision needed for future tests, with the Starship's descent showing structural failures as it disintegrated.

SpaceX's innovative rocket landing methods

  1. SpaceX's Starship/SuperHeavy launch system completed its 5th flight, showcasing significant advancements in rocket landing technology. The booster was caught by a pair of arms on a tower, eliminating the need for traditional landing legs and shock absorbers.
  2. The Starship stage successfully landed in the Indian Ocean, demonstrating precise guidance and control despite damage to its control surfaces during re-entry. This precision was highlighted by the Starship's ability to land next to a buoy equipped with a camera, capturing the landing process.
  3. The launch was initially delayed but proceeded within the scheduled window, with the early flight stages being well-rehearsed. The launch was visually striking due to the early morning sun, enhancing the visibility of the rocket's vapor trail and the shadow it cast on Earth.
  4. The critical phase of the flight involved the staging process, where engines were shut down and restarted. This phase was executed smoothly, with onboard cameras capturing the booster firing its engines as it maneuvered into position.
  5. The booster, equipped with a pin for the capture mechanism, performed a boost back burn on 13 engines, later reducing to 3 for precise entry corrections. It used grid fins for steering and cold gas thrusters for minor trajectory adjustments.
  6. The booster was launched on a trajectory to return just off the coast of Boca Chica, with its path ensuring safety in case of failure. The booster had to autonomously navigate to the landing site, using its grid fins and thrusters to guide its descent.

SpaceX's innovative rocket landing method

  1. SpaceX's Starship/SuperHeavy launch system achieved a precision touchdown with both the booster and the Starship, marking a significant advancement in rocket recovery methods.
  2. The booster was caught by a pair of arms on a tower, eliminating the need for complex landing legs and shock absorbers, showcasing a radical new recovery method.
  3. During descent, the booster emitted gas that was pulled along by the atmosphere, indicating the atmosphere's increasing density as the booster descended from 100,000 feet.
  4. The booster performed a rapid deceleration by lighting up 13 engines, then switched to three engines for fine control as it approached the tower for a catch.
  5. The maneuver was planned with safety in mind, ensuring that if the booster failed, it would miss the tower and land safely without causing damage.
  6. The capture involved the booster being caught by 'giant chopsticks' on the tower, with shock-absorbing rails to handle stress, saving weight by incorporating these into the tower.
  7. The innovative method of landing rockets by catching them at the top reduces forces throughout the vehicle, potentially allowing for more efficient and repeatable landings.

SpaceX's innovative rocket recovery methods

  1. SpaceX's Starship/SuperHeavy launch system achieved a significant milestone with its 5th flight, demonstrating precision touchdown for both the booster and the Starship. The booster was caught by a pair of arms on a tower, eliminating the need for landing legs and shock absorbers.
  2. The Starship stage flew to the Indian Ocean, achieving a precision landing next to a buoy with a camera, despite sustaining damage to its control surfaces during entry. This showcased the accuracy of its guidance system.
  3. The booster recovery involved purging parts of the fuel system to prevent potential explosions, followed by a series of processes to safely secure the booster.
  4. Starship ascended on a suborbital trajectory, reaching a maximum altitude of 22 km, and was capable of reaching orbital speed, though it did not complete an orbit.
  5. The heat shield of the Starship had undergone redesigns, including an ablative layer for additional thermal protection in case of missing tiles. Some tiles were intentionally removed to test the vehicle's resilience.
  6. During re-entry, the Starship had to navigate through different atmospheric regimes, maintaining the correct attitude to manage heat and drag. The stainless steel body faced away from the main heating, with RCS thrusters and fins used for control.
  7. The Starship's descent involved active control with fins to maintain attitude and precision targeting, aiming for a future where landing legs are unnecessary, and the vehicle can be caught mid-air.
  8. Multiple cameras provided different views of the Starship's re-entry and descent, capturing details like the color changes on the fins due to heat and sparks from the heat shield.

Successful precision landing despite fin damage

  1. The text discusses the challenges faced by SpaceX's Starship during re-entry, particularly focusing on the heating issues of the forward fins. The left forward fin is observed to be heated from behind, possibly due to missing tiles or hot gas penetration.
  2. The forward fins, attached to a curved surface, face difficulties in sealing, leading to higher pressures or temperatures at certain points. Despite these challenges, the rear fins appear to be in better condition, with only minor hot spots noted.
  3. The right forward fin shows signs of failure due to hot gas penetration, resulting in the loss of control surface chunks. However, the damage is less severe compared to previous flights, raising questions about the vehicle's ability to withstand atmospheric re-entry.
  4. As the Starship descends to 45 km altitude, its speed reduces to below 10,000 km/h. The heating shifts from plasma to thermal emission from the vehicle's surface, indicating a stable descent despite fin damage.
  5. The vehicle maintains a stable altitude and control, performing a belly flop maneuver to slow down using high drag orientation. This reduces the need for engine burns, conserving propellant stored in header tanks.
  6. The engines ignite for landing, with reflections visible on the vehicle's steel surface. The Starship lands at a slight angle, aiming for potential recovery of parts for analysis, despite a violent end with a propellant explosion.
  7. The landing occurs near a buoy equipped with a camera, capturing the event. Despite the explosion, some parts remain afloat, showcasing the engineering prowess in achieving a soft, on-target landing despite significant control surface damage.
  8. The text concludes by highlighting the success of the guidance software and the need to address heat shield issues, while acknowledging the achievement of catching a booster as a significant milestone.

SpaceX's innovative rocket recovery method

  1. SpaceX successfully conducted the 5th flight of their Starship/SuperHeavy launch system, marking a significant advancement in their space exploration efforts. This mission demonstrated a new recovery method for the booster, which involved maneuvering the rocket next to a tower to be caught by a pair of arms, eliminating the need for traditional landing legs and shock absorbers.
  2. The Starship stage of the mission flew to the Indian Ocean, where it executed a precision landing next to a buoy equipped with a camera. This landing showcased the accuracy of the guidance system, even after the control surfaces sustained damage during entry.
  3. The success of this mission suggests that SpaceX may be able to proceed to the next launch more quickly, as the risk mitigation factors have been successfully demonstrated. This could potentially allow for a faster turnaround between launches without needing to change the flight license.
  4. The ultimate goal for SpaceX is to scale up the Starship and SuperHeavy systems to fulfill their intended missions, which include rapid reusability and efficient space travel. The recent achievements indicate progress towards these objectives, although there is still significant work to be done.